| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Work with all your cloud files (Drive, Dropbox, and Slack and Gmail attachments) and documents (Google Docs, Sheets, and Notion) in one place. Try Dokkio (from the makers of PBworks) for free. Now available on the web, Mac, Windows, and as a Chrome extension!

View
 

R5-Ecosystem-Challenges

Page history last edited by Chris Jones 9 years, 7 months ago

Exploring Med-Ed Ecosystem Synergies & Challenges

#k12 #ecosys #edreform #hcsm #hcr #healthcare

 

ECOSYS is working to unpack social ecosystem challenges and barriers. What's happening that works against our target outcomes? Commonalities might shed some light, so our current focus for March-April 2012 is comparing Healthcare & K12 Education. 

 

Note: we began K12 Objectives & Definitions in our R1 (Social Contract) Purpose of Education segment (pardon the mess, this is a work in progress !!)

 

CHAT OUTLINE for 3/25-4/15 9p EDT.

 

  • Q1 What are similarities between Healthcare and K12 Education? Do patients & students share hurdles?
    • Money goes into salaries, not service
    • Both are silo'd bureaucracies; practitioners in both must embrace change more quickly
    • K12 can benefit from "instructional rounds" used in HC 
    • Neither HC or K12 are sufficiently creative 
    • ACSD12 and UVa conversations re: HC & K12 (links to follow) 
    • HC medicates when broken; K12 obsessed with remediation 
  • Q2 What about issues of Choice across HCR & K12?
    • Generally choice is highly limited, especially for Rural K12 
    • In K12, 'private' choice carries high price tag and for most equates to "no choice"
    • K12 more supervised than HC, though HC can carry higher (near-term) stakes 
  • Q3 How does the Political Dynamic play out in HCR & K12?
    • HC & K12 perceived as human needs, but allocated based on wealth
    • HC & ED both work to maintain order
    • Generally, politicians "talk the good talk" w/ no direct benefit/effect/action .. say what they need to say to get elected 
  • Q4 What can we learn re: Performance Measurement gaps across HCR & K12?
    • HC docs viewed as advanced professionals, teachers less so
    • Years of education factors into levels of trust, pay .. HC > EDU 
    • ED increasingly obsessed w/ measurement, HC not
    • ED reliance on test scores is faulty 
  • Q5 How does money motivate in HCR & ED? Are incentive controls alike, or diff?
    • CN HC free, basic, but wealthy get what they need; is this direction for US EDU? What can be done to avoid this?
    • Obamacare a 1st step toward HC as a right (much work to do) 
    • Money not flowing to right places? (begs Q:) Where is it flowing? 

  NEW Breakouts at 4/22 & 4/29 

  • Q5a Economic Impact due to Fin Crisis & Cuts at State/County level
  • Q5b Market Forces (Textbook Co's)
  • Q5c Change from MFG to SVC Model; means to move away from Factory Model of ED? tee up for 4/30 !?
  • Q5d FINANCIAL COMPARISON - launched 4/29 p.m. - stand by for categories & prelim data

 

IDEAS FROM 4/15 (CJ): Excited about the depth/breadth of topics we surfaced tonight, as expansion on points raised; let's pull from these IDEAS for upcoming #MEDED topics; stay tuned for updates:

CANDIDATE TOPICS

01 Q3/A3: Socialization vs. "Rights" re: US ED & > US MED; w/ CN differences?

02 Q3/A3: Capitalism vs. Democracy impacts (free market, free elections .. ) 

03 Q3/A3: CN ED aligning w/ US ED w/ right-wing candidates?

04 Q3/A3: Decentralization, closer to problems; Role of FEDS vs. CN (Province) / US (State)

05 Q4/A4: Measuring wrong things in ED > Assessment topic?

06 Q5/A5: Text Book & Drug Co's for-profit, due to economics (capital intensive, slow to change)

07 Q5/A5: Money not flowing where needed > See Q5d FINANCIAL COMPARISON Above

08 A5: CN MED: Free, Basic, Rich get what they need; similar to US ED?

09 More CN Case Studies

10 More on Economics & Human Rights (PDF-can someone do a synopsis?) 

11 US higher highs, lower lows; why not in CN?

IDEAS FROM ASYNC (aggregated by CJ):

 12 Q5: What if gov't invested in teachers & students as much as they did in "standardized malpractice"? @drtimony

 

Link to Transcript for 4/15

Please RT and/or Favorite additional tweets for anything we missed.

 

What is Ecosys?

It's a conversation about change in our social ecosystems, currently focused on K12 Education.  Here's more on our framing and our wiki frontpage brightspots topics and our challenges frame.

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.